Институт социологии
Российской академии наук

Anton Oleinik, Irina Popova, Svetlana Kirdina, Tatyana Shatalova. On the choice of measures of reliability and validity in the content-analysis of texts ...



Anton Oleinik, Irina Popova, Svetlana Kirdina, Tatyana Shatalova. On the choice of measures of reliability and validity in the content-analysis of texts // Quality & Quantity, 2014, Volume 48, Issue 5 (2014), Page 2703-2718.
ISSN 0033-5177 (print version)

Размещена на сайте: 20.08.14

Поискать полный текст на Google Academia

Моя книжная полка

Ссылка при цитировании:

Anton Oleinik, Irina Popova, Svetlana Kirdina, Tatyana Shatalova. On the choice of measures of reliability and validity in the content-analysis of texts // Quality & Quantity, 2014, Volume 48, Issue 5 (2014), Page 2703-2718.

Аннотация

The paper discusses several reliability measures: Scott’s pi, Krippendorff’s alpha, free marginal adjustment (Bennett, Alpert and Goldstein’s S), Cohen’s kappa, and Perreault and Leigh’s I and the assumptions on which they are based. It is suggested that correlation coefficients between, on one hand, the distribution of qualitative codes and, on the other hand, word co-occurrences and the distribution of the categories identified with the help of the dictionary based on substitution complement the other reliability measures. The paper shows that the choice of the reliability measure depends on the format of the text (stylistic versus rhetorical) and the type of reading (comprehension versus interpretation). Namely, Cohen’s kappa and Bennett, Alpert and Goldstein’s S emerge as reliability measures particularly suited for perspectival reading of rhetorical texts. Outcomes of the content analysis of 57 texts performed by four coders with the help of computer program QDA Miner inform the analysis.

Ключевые слова:

reliability measures content analysis correlation content analysis interpretation comprehension stylistic texts rhetorical texts контент-анализ интерпретация понимание стилистические тексты риторические тексты

Авторы:

Попова И.П.

Рубрики:

Методология социологии
Методы сбора и анализа социологических данных



Возможно, вам будут интересны другие публикации:



КОММЕНТАРИИ К ЭТОЙ СТРАНИЦЕ



rss подписаться на RSS ленту комментариев к этой странице
ОСТАВИТЬ КОММЕНТАРИЙ
Комментарии. Всего [0]: